Whether you want to call it a rib or a serious criticism, Lead Core Gameplay Designer on Battlefield 4 Alex Kertz had his own response to Metal Gear Solid V’s Quiet.

He tweeted the following comparing real life women soldiers to the one we see in Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain.

What female soldiers really look like: http://t.co/rYwsvidrCk What female soldiers don't look like: http://t.co/QKseakt4PS

— Alan Kertz (@Demize99) September 6, 2013

The first link (seen above) showcases what female Swedish soldiers look like, decked out in full combat gear, same as any male soldier would be. The second link showcases a profile shot of Quiet, in all her revealing glory. What started this barrage of criticism against Quiet’s design was director Hideo Kojima stating that he wanted to make his female characters more “erotic” (which he later clarified as a mis-translation).

Of course, when told that this was fantasy military as compared to realistic military, Kertz responded:

@GordonVanDyke It's fantasy something.

— Alan Kertz (@Demize99) September 6, 2013

But he did admit defeat in one department, which Battlefield as a series hasn’t had (and still doesn’t have, at least not that we know of, in Battlefield 4):

@GordonVanDyke Touché.

— Alan Kertz (@Demize99) September 6, 2013

While Kertz may have a point, are we forgetting that Metal Gear Solid is a series wherein a female soldier was raised by wolves to become a sniper, an entire unit composed of beautiful females trapped in cybernetic exoskeletons and The Boss exist? The symbolism of Quiet may be the key rather than how much skin she reveals, but everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

What are your thoughts on the matter? Let us know in the comments below.