Yes and no.. The company asked MS to provided them with sufficient information to answer the question of relative comparison reliability to their satisfaction and MS haven’t done so…. MS could have done it to clear the air but didn’t.

@disqus_eidelyn:disqus is in the right here and you’ve said nothing to discredit it. all you’ve been going in is that Microsoft could have done this or that, but in actuality they don’t need to do anything, they’re under no obligation to do so, correct?

After that post MS could have shown that BC was a very good feature used by gamers to everyone but they didn’t. MS could have shown what was needed but didn’t.

Jesus, let me just paste this comment I read on Arstechnica, maybe it will let you understand where the problem resides:
“I invent a new type of microscope. I use it to measure Ebola, influenza and Polio and I publish the measurements.

A medical firm that OWNS A REAL MICROSCOPE calls me and says “your microscope isn’t working. We’ve measured Polio and it’s different then your number”

I reply by saying “well that sucks. But I’m sure Ebola and influenza’s measurements are JUST FINE!”

You can’t do science with a broken or miscalibrated instrument. You can’t do math on a data set collected with a methodology that isn’t accurate 100% of the time.

Period.”

If you don’t grasp the meaning of it, I don’t know how to explain it.

4K hah ill be downsampling from 5K, 4K is for last gen systems!

Nothing was handed to them to show what MS stated was correct, hence why they stated “going forward we will refer to the data generated by this
source as a “player” report, rather than an “ownership” report”

Where are the actual MS stats that MS talks about as the people have asked and MS have shown nothing? They have asked MS but MS haven’t given stats to them…why?

Click bait or not MS could have shown that BC was a very good feature used by gamers but they didn’t.

Apparently it was enough to make them withdraw their previous work.

They have asked MS but MS haven’t given stats to them. Maybe MS should release stats to back up their claims too

I don’t know, ask ArseTechica.
While you’re at it, ask them how they managed to effe up those stats, too.

No matter what is posted, what I copied from that link is correct.

Where are the actual MS stats?

https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/06/correction-undercounted-usage-data-in-our-xbox-unleashed-analysis/?comments=1