Elden Ring Nightreign’s The Forsaken Hollows Gets “Mixed” Steam Rating, Fans Bemoan Lack of Content

Some fans are left wondering why FromSoftware didn't add any weapons, spells or Ashes of War from Shadow of the Erdtree.

Posted By | On 04th, Dec. 2025

Elden Ring Nightreign The Forsaken Hollows - Balancers

Available now on Xbox, PlayStation, and PC, Elden Ring Nightreign has received its first paid DLC, The Forsaken Hollows. It brings two new Nightfarers to the fray alongside two new Day 3 bosses and a new Shifting Earth event for $15. However, despite peaking at 133,355 concurrent players recently, the response is underwhelming on Steam.

The Forsaken Hollows currently has a “Mixed” rating with only 46 percent of the 1,171 user reviews recommending it. The common complaint seems to be the lack of new weapons or items outside of the unique weapons the Scholar and Undertaker start with (which aren’t all that special).

As one review notes, “Why didn’t they add the Elden Ring DLC weapons, Ashes of War, or spells? That feels like a MASSIVE mistake, and I am genuinely heartbroken that we can’t get those items in this game,” referring to the items from Shadow of the Erdtree.”

Another says the DLC doesn’t do enough to shake up the map variety, even with the Great Hollows. “This flaw is not adequately addressed in this DLC, where we get a whopping one Shifting Earth event, which introduces a map that is aesthetically mesmerizing, but disappointing in every other respect. The Great Hollows would be fun to explore without the time crunch, but with that limitation, I feel no incentive to explore it at all.”

Of course, given the post-launch support for the base game, FromSoftware could very well add more events, weapons, items, and so on. Bigger additions to Limveld might be reserved for future DLC, if there’s anything planned beyond The Forsaken Hollows.


Keep On Reading!

Memory Prices Might “Never” Come Back Down, Says Lenovo Executive

Memory Prices Might “Never” Come Back Down, Says Lenovo Executive

Martin Hiegl spoke about this during a presentation at ISC 2026 in light of high price tags for gaming console...

Grand Theft Auto 6, Mario Kart World Could Lead to More Games Priced at $80, Says Analyst

Grand Theft Auto 6, Mario Kart World Could Lead to More Games Priced at $80, Says Analyst

According to Joost van Dreunen, however, other companies will have a hard time in reaching the bar set by Gran...

Ubisoft Barcelona Employees Are Going On Strike to Protest 51 Layoffs From Restructuring

Ubisoft Barcelona Employees Are Going On Strike to Protest 51 Layoffs From Restructuring

The employees have demanded that Ubisoft not layoff anyone at the studio and follow through on promised promot...

Xbox Freezes Game Pass Deals for Third-Party Studios – Rumor

Xbox Freezes Game Pass Deals for Third-Party Studios – Rumor

Arrowhead Game Studios CEO Shams Jorjani believes that the Helldivers 2 developer might have signed its final ...

Stranger Than Heaven’s Story is “Very Extensive,” But Features Fewer Play Spots Than Yakuza

Stranger Than Heaven’s Story is “Very Extensive,” But Features Fewer Play Spots Than Yakuza

The maps are also "roughly the same scale" as the Yakuza series, though each has a distinct size, says RGG Stu...

Marvel Tōkon: Fighting Souls Highlights Ms. Marvel’s Flexible Moves and Hard-Hitting Combos

Marvel Tōkon: Fighting Souls Highlights Ms. Marvel’s Flexible Moves and Hard-Hitting Combos

With stunning elasticity and the ability to increase the size of her limbs, Kamala Khan can move fast and dish...