Gears of War 4 For Xbox One: The Evolution vs. The Innovation of Bad-ass Bloodshed

Does killing in the Gears of War universe really have to feel different, or can it just be fun every time?

Killer Instinct creator Ken Lobb had a very interesting comment about Black Tusk Studios and their upcoming Gears of War title for the Xbox One. He said the game would be “innovative” and that there were a ton of interesting ideas for the next bloody chapter.

When one looks back and thinks about the first Gears of War, it’s amazing to forget how much the game innovated.

It changed the way we looked at third person shooters. No longer were you zipping around levels, playing third person platformer while dealing with enemies. Now you were meandering around, dealing with your own bulky weight and dying out in the open. It was for this purpose that developer Epic Games decided to mimic “real warfare” and have you rely primarily on cover. The rules were simple: Find cover or die trying.

Who cares if it isn't set in the modern day. Gears of War 3 is still set to make a splash when it launches later this year

It wasn’t its mechanics that made Gears of War innovative or outright amazing but they helped bring its essence to the forefront of gamers’ minds.

But that’s not all. Gears of War also introduced the Active Reload, which had you carefully timing your button presses to properly reload. A wrong reload caused your gun to jam. A proper reload saw you ready your weapon that much faster and a true Active Reload meant the next few bullets (or potentially the whole clip) received a damage boost. In the midst of finding covering, struggling to reload and mowing down foes that were extremely dangerous even in pairs; Gears of War delivered a palpable, hellish experience that had you on the edge of your seat.

Of course, the main mind behind Gears of War, Cliff Bleszinski, didn’t stop there. The game’s intensity was further enhanced by a near-lethal injection of violence, post-apocalyptic genocide and outright brutality. Chainsaws attached to assault rifles chopped Locust to pieces. You could brutally execute enemies on the ground or gib them into several pieces using explosives, perhaps best exemplified by the Hammer of Dawn’s concentrated laser from heaven.

Mix in some water-cooler moments inspired by Resident Evil 4 – the encounter with the Brumak, the first fight with the Berserker, laying siege to Locust barracks, fighting off General RAAM on a train, navigating the brutal darkness as enemy Kryll waited till all was dark – and Gears of War for its time was one of the craziest and most outright insane shooters out there. And that’s not even counting its biggest contribution to cooperative multiplayer with Horde Mode.

It wasn’t its mechanics that made Gears of War innovative or outright amazing but they helped bring its essence to the forefront of gamers’ minds. Even as Gears of War 2 and 3 shifted the focus towards more cover-based shooting and narrative-focused murder respectively, the action shooter’s many layers left us wanting for more.

gears-of-war-judgment-2

This is the main obstacle that lies before Gears of War 4. In attempting to keep the game firmly entrenched in Locust-massacring territory, Judgment acted as a prequel but Gears 4 can’t bury its head in the sands of time.

Which brings us to Gears of War 4 and reminds us of Gears of War: Judgment, another game in the series that wasn’t developed by Epic Games (it was actually handled by Bulletstorm developer People Can Fly). Judgment took the traditional Gears of War experience and attempted to add its own hooks. You can choose tougher variants of missions. The enemy count was significantly higher.

Newer weapons were added along with newer enemy varieties. Horde Mode had been incorporated into the single-player campaign while Survival took a more class-based, defense-focused objective. All in all, it was a solid Gears of War experience but did it really offer much distinction between “hook” and “innovation”?

This is the main obstacle that lies before Gears of War 4. In attempting to keep the game firmly entrenched in Locust-massacring territory, Judgment acted as a prequel but Gears 4 can’t bury its head in the sands of time. It needs to make a solid effort at moving forward.

So why not set the game several decades or even centuries after the first? The Locust Horde itself resulted from early human Lambents and their mutated genes being passed down to their children. The Horde then found itself torn between fighting the divergent Lambents and being pushed towards Sera’s surface to establish its own home. The Locust formed the basis for a lot of Gears of Wars’ gameplay – would it be a cop out to bring them back again? It would, if they suddenly just reappeared in full force. So why not a slow evolutionary return, entrenched in the annals of human corruption and conspiracy that finally sees them make their triumphant return by game’s end?

Gears of War_Skorge

With regards to the game’s mechanics, it makes sense to incorporate some form of linear mission progression intermixed with the ability to race around a giant set piece and murder enemies.

The only problem with this route would be the placebo enemies that the player would need to cut down throughout the game. This isn’t Gears of War without insane cover-based warfare and the Lambent reappearing would just be a similar dilemma. So why not have a cult built around the Locust, one that worships the teachings of Skorge and swears by Queen Meera in the middle of another civil war between the various factions of humanity?

The cult could slowly swell in power before declaring open war as their attempts to bring back the Locust come to fruition. This serves to paint the Locust in a new political light – that of an alternate solution befitting of humanity’s current state but one steeped in past horrors.

With regards to the game’s mechanics, it makes sense to incorporate some form of linear mission progression intermixed with the ability to race around a giant set piece and murder enemies. It would be akin to Halo’s open air battles which promised multiple approaches, vehicles and tactics towards successfully killing enemies.

We’ve seen hints of such open air areas in the Gears of franchise but within a tighter area – and without the feeling of “Go there and do this thing before doubling back and doing the other thing” – it could help lend that urgency of war without compromising on the in-your-face intensity that the series if known for.

gears of war sera

However, the one thing that Black Tusk Studios shouldn’t compromise on with Gears of War 4 is the series’ spirit. It’s about killing. It’s about staying alive and it’s about being a bad-ass about it.

Active Reload shouldn’t be scrapped but it should be built. Deliver damage multipliers for successive Active Reloads. Send out enemies that can only be taken down in this fashion or at least structure certain difficulties in such a way that these multipliers will be necessary. Allow gamers to customize their load outs at the beginning of each mission along with different Perks and Abilities. Give them different equipment to further distinguish themselves from their friends and have these character load outs carry over into multiplayer/co-op.

Most importantly, Gears of War 4 should incorporate some form of persistent multiplayer. Have up to 16 players fighting together in the campaign, turning the exercise into one gigantic Horde campaign, and throw in those same open air missions for some additional carnage. There is so much that could be done with the next game in the series that it’s plain crazy to think about.

However, the one thing that Black Tusk Studios shouldn’t compromise on with Gears of War 4 is the series’ spirit. It’s about killing. It’s about staying alive and it’s about being a bad-ass about it. Plot, characterization, dialogue wheels, sandbox elements and whatnot are some nice hooks but at the end of the day, it’s about chain sawing an enemy to bits for the 1000th time and still feeling like it means something.


  • Kevin Kirby

    POS4 has no games

    • CervantesPR
    • Guy Brohski

      What is there to reply to? Ubisoft hasn’t confirmed the res for either platform, so there isn’t even a scoop there. Dualshockers is the trashiest tabloid game site ever, btw. Why are you muddling this thread with a link to that garbage website anyway?

    • CervantesPR

      Well kevin kirby like to talk a lot of trash about ps4 and talks nonsense about xbox and it getting more powerful than the ps4 lol so i told him that i would get back to him once resolutions for watchdogs were announced to prove him wrong once again i just wanna see his damage control but he avoiding me lol
      Dualshockers is the best gaming news website i know you must hate it cuz its pro sony hence the name but they are actually pretty fair towards xbox.

    • Guy Brohski

      I’m not doubting that the Xbone will have a lower resolution, I’m sure it will. But let’s at least wait until it’s confirmed by Digital Foundry before we go bashing the Xbone version’s resolution. XP

    • TrippyMack

      well if you think playstation never really has any software changes to the console except the playstation store as far as ps3 while xbox 360 has gone through many software changes since it was first released. So id expect the same thing, the xbox one is still in its premature stage as an xbox 720

  • NFI

    No. God no. The Locust are dead. There is nothing to ‘pass down”. They didn’t “evolve”. They should not be brought back, they need to go back to the beginning and do an Eday game. However miraculously bringing the locust back is terrible. There are no traits to pass along, all lambent cells were killed and the locust at their core were lambent containing organisms. All of them died. No one wants to see a game that pretty much makes everything Delta squad did irrelevant, makes all the main characters who died pointless, and the entire ending a waste as the theme was it is over, they said it was over.

    The only thing that makes any sense is a game from the beginning of it all, EDAY. Give us a young marcus fenix and dom santiago, and have at it.

    • Cole Fisher

      That would be boring and pointless cuz we already know what happens. You’re a glass half empty just like the rest of the community that want a prequel of a prequel. I mean WTF would be the point of that. U are very innovated ‘lets make games backwards and then forwards again’. You should give it another thought sir and bow down to the man who wrote this cog worthy scripture of Gears awesomness.

    • Joe Allen

      I think they should move forward do 4,5,6 ect then make a comeback after another decade and do Emergence Day. I will be happy either way as long as its done right.

    • Cole Fisher

      That’s what I’m talking about! And I hope Black Tusk can somehow balance the weapons better than in gears 3 too. Gnasher needs to be a long range weapon and sawed off has to be close range or vise versa don’t yell at me yet fans! Balancing and more awesomeness is needed!

    • Jamie Stevens

      Gnasher is a shotgun, not a assault rifle, it’s range is perfectly fine in gears, if not too far. Sawed off is already a close range and overpowered shotgun, but then its reload rate and single fire balance that out to the Gnasher.

  • CervantesPR

    Gears of war 5 and foward to be milked for xbox one for the rest of the generation by an unknown developer. Same with halo. Poor xbox. Lmao now that bungie and epic left microsoft what does microsoft have? Lol fail

    • Carlos

      PR, so you’re Sony’s public’s relations person huh?

    • Cole Fisher

      Lol fail troll

  • Joe Allen

    I think the active reload multiplayer is an awesome idea, and maybe even add certain effects for getting several in a row (fire, electric, acid bullets). Although, I would hate to see the game get too complicated, I like the way it was so simple. Its Gears, blood, violence, grub stompin fun

  • http://www.MySlackerMind.com/ Matt Gorman

    If they were to do a prequel, I’d want them to focus on Carlos (Dom’s brother).

  • Jfdelman

    One of the worst gaming franchises ever.

    • Guy Brohski

      Nah, Killzone takes that cake easy. Just look at the cummulated scores of that crappy series and that pretty much explains it.

    • Jfdelman

      Never played kz, but there’s no way it can be worse than gears. I prefer kz art and style, so even without gameplay it’s winning. I didn’t know scores meant a game is better than another.

    • Guy Brohski

      Well when a game series consistently scores as low as KZ, it tells you something. Killzone and Gears both have good graphics, but that’s where the similarity ends. People actually still play Gears 1 online. But try and find someone playing KZ 2 or 3 online, and you’ll find a barren wasteland long deserted by humans.

  • Guy Brohski

    Gears of War 4 will have the best graphics of any console game ever, just like Gears 1 when it first released. I remember laughing at how bad Resistance looked next to it, lmao!

  • richard6272

    The adoration of Ganapati has become actual accepted now-a-days. Ganesha puja is actuality acclaimed with abundant adherence and activity by the accouchement throughoukanipakam vinayaka templet India.I quickly informed him that I was there to start work. I was looking for an entrance to the security desk to get my credentials.If so then you most likely understand that you will need to immediately take to the internet in order to acquire the latest in Asian clothing. Many department stores and local clothing stores don carry cheap Asian fashion.Changing up your look is another way to express yourself. Being inspired by such things helps create who you are and what image you want to convey to the world.

    Let’s face it; kids have excellent days and they have days that are tougher. If a child takes up attitude or has some sort of complaint, I always start off by saying, “I understand,” and I nike air max 90 for sale say it in a sincere manner.There were no canned foods and little refrigeration. People also had little knowledge of nutrition.If you are so inclined, you could even give your creations for free to your friends. Whatever you plan to make of your new skill, hopefully you’d have a good time doing it.Des objets comme des http://www.skycatmall.co.uk/nike-lunarglide-4-c-78/ accoutrements ordinateur roulettes sont appropries sur le skate passe par un accord abondante l’abrasion et la dchirure, ce sujet ne vous sera factur annoncer absorber tableau de l’argent l’avertissement accumuler votre planche de skate. A titre d’archtype si vous riche appel accoutrements ordinateur, vous pouvez en fait aller en ligne et rechercher dans les accoutrements de skate lattes informatiques ralisables l’achat.

    It can be developed with numerous difficult major technique and imagination to create specific that our entire purchasers get addicted and pleased toward our warm and sizzling style planet with this yr 2010. you’ll find a lot of advantages precisely where just about each and every certain could get satisfaction from the comfort zones of Nike grownup males shoes for instance trendy lace-up is entirely leather-based lined, Exotic fabric, Calf leather, Rubber primary skin, Handmade item, excellent

    “But he’s also got more attitude than you’d expect from a robot. In recent years they’ve added characters Nike Air Max 1 For Sale such as Miss America Chavez and the Zapata Brothers.IRVING — Sort Phillips will stay the top trainer from the Dallas Cowboys with regard to a minumum of one much more period, based on ESPN Erectile dysfunction Werder. The actual Cowboys tend to be reeling through Sunday 34-3 reduction towards the Vikings, however evidently their own overall performance lower the actual extend Cheap NFL Jerseys Free Shipping and also the very first playoff earn within 13 many years had been sufficient in order to generate Phillips an additional period.

  • Kelvin Roy Leek

    you don’t understand gears was about simple choices what gun to use not having multiple different load outs that give people that’s been playing a long time an advantage, if im fighting you with a gnasher its about skill not if you have a better perk unlocked. that’s what made gears !!!!!

44 queries. 9.003 seconds