10 Fan Favorite Games That Received Mixed Critical Responses

These titles may not have met with the most positive critical responses but have been appreciated by players throughout the years.

Posted By | On 12th, Jul. 2021

Page 1 of 10

Like many things in this world, there will be differing opinions on games. One person may enjoy role-playing games while others find them boring, no matter how much praise a certain title has received. Another person may enjoy sports titles like Madden year in and year out without fail. While the very tenet of “differing opinions” is a basic and altogether human quality, it’s still interesting to look back on video games over the years to compare critical and fan reactions. Let’s take a look at 10 games with mixed critical responses that fans still embraced.

Days Gone

Perhaps the most recent example on this list is Days Gone. First revealed at E3 2016, its main calling card was the sizable hordes of undead on-screen that players could battle. It was originally slated to release in 2018 but faced a number of delays before finally launching in April 2019. On Metacritic, it averaged a 71 out of 109 reviews from critics. Some gameplay and world building aspects were praised but critics were ultimately harsh on the game for its mission design, writing, performance and myriad of bugs. While not an outright terrible review average, it was a shock to PS4 players, especially with how revered Sony’s exclusive first-party offerings had become.

After its launch, however, Days Gone attained a relatively strong following with players becoming attached to the characters and the overall world design. Bend Studio would also update the game frequently, adding new challenges, difficulty modes and bug fixes. It eventually became clear that Days Gone wouldn’t be getting a sequel or even a major expansion. Earlier this year, Jason Schreier spoke to sources that revealed a sequel proposal being rejected due to the first game’s mixed critical response and long development period. Nevertheless, a PC version arrived in May and fans have started a petition for a sequel. Bend Studio is currently working on a new IP built on “the deep open-world systems that they have developed with Days Gone” as per PlayStation Studios head Herman Hulst so at the very least, its DNA carries over in some ways.


Amazing Articles You Might Want To Check Out!

Keep On Reading!

Borderlands 4’s Endgame is “Very Ambitious,” Says Creative Director

Borderlands 4’s Endgame is “Very Ambitious,” Says Creative Director

Gearbox's Graeme Timmins said the team has "thought about" the shooter's endgame "from the jump" and has some ...

Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch – New Game Plus Update is Live, 3 New Weapons Also Added

Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch – New Game Plus Update is Live, 3 New Weapons Also Added

Those who finished the game can embark on multiple New Game+ cycles against tougher enemies and uncover improv...

Jurassic World Evolution 3 Trailer Showcases the Lokiceratops

Jurassic World Evolution 3 Trailer Showcases the Lokiceratops

As a ceratopsian, the Lokiceratops is distinguished by its curved horns and social nature, though it can be fi...

Splitgate 2 Interview – Post-Launch Content, Player Feedback, Console Performance, and More

Splitgate 2 Interview – Post-Launch Content, Player Feedback, Console Performance, and More

Co-founder and CEO of 1047 Games Ian Proulx was kind enough to answer some of our questions about competitive ...

ROUTINE is Still in Active Development, Approaching “The Finish Line”

ROUTINE is Still in Active Development, Approaching “The Finish Line”

Regarding the release date, developer Lunar Software is "confident that we’ll be able to share more news on ...

Steel Hunters is Ending Development With Servers Shutting Down on October 8th

Steel Hunters is Ending Development With Servers Shutting Down on October 8th

After entering early access in April, Wargaming says that "continuing development" on the free-to-play PvEvP s...